Is Overstock Jewelry Real? (All You Need To Know)

Last Updated on March 24, 2022

Overstock is a well-known e-commerce site with thousands of products available at the click of a mouse. But with so many options available, you might be wondering: Is Overstock jewelry real?

We’ll answer this question and more, including:

  • What is Overstock?
  • Is Overstock jewelry good quality?
  • Why is Overstock jewelry so cheap?
  • Does Overstock sell real diamonds?
  • Is Overstock a good place to buy an engagement ring?
  • Are Overstock jewelry items new?
  • Does Overstock have sales?
  • Can Overstock products be returned?
  • How to save even more money at Overstock?

Let’s jump right in and take a look at the question on everyone’s mind:


Is Overstock Jewelry Real?

The short answer is yes, jewelry sold through Overstock is real. However, while Overstock states all diamonds within their marketplace are 100% authentic, not all of their diamonds are GIA certified.

So What Is Overstock? is an online e-commerce platform founded in 1999 by Patrick M. Byrne. Starting from humble beginnings, Overstock is now a billion-dollar online retailer stocking almost any item imaginable.

Is Overstock Jewelry Good Quality?

Overstock jewelry is as good of quality as other department stores and jewelry retailers. This is because Overstock stocks surplus items from department stores and jewelry retailers.  

Why Is Overstock Jewelry So Cheap?

Because Overstock serves as a clearinghouse for overstock inventory from large companies, the retailer is able to sell items at discounted prices compared to traditional retailers. 

Does Overstock Sell Real Diamonds?

Yes, Overstock sells 100% authentic diamonds. However, not all diamonds sold by Overstock are GIA certified diamonds.

Is Overstock Gold Real?

Yes, Overstock sells real gold jewelry at affordable prices.

Is Overstock a Good Place to Buy an Engagement Ring?

Yes. Overstock receives consistently positive reviews from customers who have purchased engagement rings and bridal sets from the retailer. 

Are Overstock Jewelry Items New?

Yes. Overstock sells new items that are surplus inventory from other big-box retailers and department stores.

Is Overstock Trustworthy?

Yes, Overstock has a trusted and reliable reputation for stocking unused liquidated items at discounted prices.

Does Overstock Have Sales?

Yes, Overstock offers daily sales on a variety of items, including jewelry.

Does Overstock Have a Rewards Program?

Yes! Shoppers can join the Overstock Club O rewards program and earn 5% on every purchase.

Can Overstock Products Be Returned?

Yes, Overstock products that are unopened and in original condition are eligible for return and refund. 

How Long Does Shipping Take From Overstock?

Most items from Overstock are shipped within 1-2 business days.

Is Overstock Shipping Free?

Yes, Overstock offers free shipping on orders shipped within the lower 48 states. 

How To Save Even More at Overstock?

While Overstock is already an affordable outlet for jewelry, customers can save even more by:

Joining the Club O Rewards Program

For a small annual fee, customers can join the Overstock Club O rewards program and receive a variety of benefits including:

  • 5% earned on every purchase
  • Price match guarantee
  • Free returns
  • Double rewards for reviews
  • Refer a friend 

Signing Up For Overstock Omail

Enroll to receive the Overstock Omail newsletter and receive 15% off of your first purchase.

Checking The Overstock Website Daily

Be sure to check the Overstock website for daily deals and sales. 

Shop Semi-Annual Sales

Overstock extends up to 70% off items during the two semi-annual sales events, which typically occur in Spring and Fall.

Teachers, Service Members, and First Responders

Qualified individuals who are educators, service members, and first responders are eligible to join the Club O rewards program for free and enjoy the many benefits offered by Overstock.

Is It Worth Shopping for Jewelry at Overstock?

Yes! Shopping for jewelry at Overstock is a great idea for shoppers looking to snag jewelry at discounted prices. And while not all diamonds sold through Overstock are GIA certified, the quality and price are hard to beat. 

Jackie Palmer is a Houston-based coin journalist and fashion enthusiast. She joined Jewels Advisor’s content team after years of experience as a content strategist, managing blogs and social channels for local stores. Jackie mostly collects and studies US coins produced during the 20th century and over the years, published hundreds of articles for multiple coin publications.